Login | Register
Enrol now for our new online tutoring program. Learn from the best tutors. Get amazing results. Learn more.

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

March 09, 2021, 11:17:56 am

Author Topic: Biomedicine at Monash vs UniMelb: Which is better?  (Read 422 times)  Share 

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

pinkblossoms

  • Adventurer
  • *
  • Posts: 8
  • Respect: 0
Biomedicine at Monash vs UniMelb: Which is better?
« on: January 18, 2021, 10:56:59 pm »
0
Hi everyone,

I received a 1st round offer for the Biomedicine course at UniMelb. I initially hoped for an offer for Biomed at Monash (however I don't think I will receive it as I didn't reach the prereq for 1 subject.)
For those who are completing, have completed or knows someone who is completing a Biomed course at any one of these universities, could you please give me your honest perspective on how these courses compare at these two different universities? Is the Biomed course somewhat the same level of difficulty/competitiveness at both universities? Or are they different? What is the culture like between these two universities?

My end goal is to be able to study post-grad Medicine at any university in Melbourne and I'm aware that Monash offers places to students without needing to do the GAMSAT whereas UniMelb and Deakin's post-grad Med course require GAMSAT regardless. Would it be worth it to study 1 year of Biomed at UniMelb then transfer to Monash's Biomed in hopes to study really well and not need to do the GAMSAT?  Or would it be better to suck it up and go for Deakin/UniMelb's Medicine course and do the GAMSAT?
(Distance and travelling time between these universities aren't a problem for me)

Thank you in advance for your help and advice  ;D I've been really stressed over these big decisions and would gladly appreciate anyone's opinions and perspectives towards this!
« Last Edit: January 18, 2021, 11:02:03 pm by pinkblossoms »

Sine

  • Werewolf
  • National Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *****
  • Posts: 4907
  • Respect: +1897
Re: Biomedicine at Monash vs UniMelb: Which is better?
« Reply #1 on: January 18, 2021, 11:06:27 pm »
+6
Hi pinkblossomes  :)

I did biomed @ monash but do know of others who did it at Melbourne so I have little bit of an understanding of what goes on there as well. I would say they are probably around the same difficulty but this could vary depending on what sort of electives you go for. In terms of competitiveness, I'm not sure. You aren't really competing against students since for the most part at university you get the scores you obtained regardless of how others perform (in some instances there is a little bit of scaling if assessment was too easy/hard but that is more of an exception to the rule).

In terms of culture, I found Monash to be really good. Biomed tends to get a bit of a bad reputation of people wanting others to do badly etc but I didn't ever experience that and I worked together with a lot of people which helped us all do better.

I can't really say what is better for your last question. Perhaps continuing at Melbourne could be better given you would already be settled there after a year?

Also this is a very common question so you should definitely have a look around the forums for previous answers!

tiredandstressed

  • MOTM: DEC 20
  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 201
  • pretty without the r (he/him)
  • Respect: +129
Re: Biomedicine at Monash vs UniMelb: Which is better?
« Reply #2 on: January 18, 2021, 11:36:52 pm »
+7
Hi pinkblossomes,

I'll provide some insights in studying Biomedicine @ UoM (i am incoming third year)
I have thoroughly enjoyed my degree, although challening it really has inspired me to pursue medicine, the quality of lectures are high and the coordination of the subjects have been done very well.
I agree with Sine that Biomedicine at UoM and Monash are probably around the same difficulty and both provide you with great insights to the field of biomedical science.
It is important to note, that Biomedicine @ UoM has revolutionised their first-year core subject; they have added two new subjects are cores and they provide foundations into biomedicine and seem pretty interesting (one of them doesn't even have a final exam, whilst the other is a low-stake final exam compared to past where all exams were <70%)
So I think you should take some time to have a look at Biomedicine @ UoM has to offer as I think it will be a unique and rewarding experience.
As for the Monash Biomedical Science Pathway to Graduate Entry Medicine yes it does sound like a great offer but there is only 50 seats (which is indeed very competitive) in 2017 there were 457 students enrolled into Biomedical Science @ Monash granted not all of them were competing for those 50 seats, but I hope you can see it would be good advice to sit the GAMSAT and apply for medical schools elsewhere.
Hence, when I found about this I felt like the edge the Monash Biomedical Science students have is minimal (granted still a great position to have) but in the end, I was recommended to still sit the GAMSAT anyway.
I personally think both are good choices, but if you worried about not having that edge at UoM I hope this gives insight on what the Monash Biomedical Science Pathway to Graduate Entry Medicine is and how competitive it can be.
As for the culture at UoM, I personally think the Biomd cohort is very friendly and it is very easy to get along with others and make social groups, it doesn't feel competitive since everyone is working together. I am sure there are some people who may act competitively, but you don't have to mingle with those bad vibes and I am sure you will be able to make friends and connections easily. The Biomed Student Society (BSS) is one of the greatest, I haven't met a committee who is so engaged with their faculty, they will all try to talk and greet with you and are super friendly, and are always there to help us out which is great! The BSS is very easy to reach out which is nice and complements the experience of studying Biomedicine @ UoM.
So if you do decide to stay @ UoM I believe you will enjoy what you study, you won't be overwhelmed by competition since you will be in a friendly environment, and enjoy the experience.
In this day and age, prestige holds little value (and this is coming from a UoM student) you shouldn't pick a university just because of its ranking although I won't deny that UoM is #1 for Clinical, Pre-clinical and Health in Australia, UoM has a lot more to offer than just its rank as I have previously mentioned above.
I hope this was helpful in helping you to make a decision.
If you have any questions don't hesitate to ask or you can PM me.
VCE '17-'18
2017: Biology, Psychology
2018: English, HHD, Chemistry, Methods
2019-21: Bachelor of Biomedicine (Physiology) @ UoM
My guides:
A quick guide to language and argument analysis
HHD sample questions
HHD 2019 Comprehensive examiner report analysis