He did make a double century in Perth...
Yeh, after that- all downhill..........................
You have to play consistently to do well. His failure to do that at the critical no.4 or no.5 spot cost australia big time.
Come on you can't judge a guy's career on 6 tests, it does take a great deal of temperament to get a double hundred. I guess the only problem he had was that he played in an era when Australia had a winning formula and didn't want to change it or carry someone who was struggling a bit...I mean England carried Mark Ramprakash for ages even though he couldn't perform because he was just such a classy batsman for Surrey, but that was because England didn't have the winning formula...
Basically, you have to give a guy more than 6 tests to perform before dropping him forever.
Matthew Hayden's first six tests had scores reading:
15, 5, 5, 0, 125, 0, 47, 40, 0, 14
But he still got more chances and when he continued to blow it he got dropped for two years and then returned and still didn't score but then he toured India in 2001 and all of a sudden he was fixed in the team...but yeah Hodge is probably too old now the emphasis for the selectors is on young guys Klinger, Hughes, Henriques, Warner etc.