Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

April 24, 2024, 11:51:58 pm

Author Topic: Free AOS essay Marking!  (Read 181421 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Daniyahasan

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 217
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #435 on: August 14, 2017, 07:58:22 pm »
hey guys,
so if we want to get something marked is it still 25 posts?
ATAR Goal 90

Natasha.97

  • NSW MVP - 2017
  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 618
  • ~
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #436 on: August 14, 2017, 08:04:33 pm »
hey guys,
so if we want to get something marked is it still 25 posts?

Yep! It's a permanent change that was made after Trials :)
Life is weird and crazy as heck but what can you do?

Daniyahasan

  • Forum Obsessive
  • ***
  • Posts: 217
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #437 on: August 14, 2017, 08:27:44 pm »
Yep! It's a permanent change that was made after Trials :)

oh okay thanks :)
ATAR Goal 90

kb123

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 74
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #438 on: September 03, 2017, 04:46:17 pm »
Hey kb! I definitely can, essay is attached with feedback in bold:

Spoiler
An individual, through the process of discovery, has the potential to undergo profound development as their previous values and beliefs are challenged, and when they adapt to new experiences, expose previously concealed truths. Excellent introductory sentence. You'd want to make sure these broad ideas are honed into the specific question at hand. These revelations may be indicated in numerous ways, spontaneously or due to the nature of an individual’s environment, posing challenges from the outset which dictate the discovery process and subsequently, confronting situations may arise. Although these situations can challenge an individual, they inevitably lead to new understandings of both themselves and the world. Such ideas are demonstrated in Ernesto Guevara’s memoir “The Motorcycle Diaries” (2003) and Franz Kafka’s novella “Metamorphosis” (1912). Good introduction, provided you are ready to hone it in to whatever question you ask. I'd also like to see you go into the specific messages the composers of these texts are conveying to their audiences - You've gone over the ideas conceptually/broadly, a little breakdown of the purpose of each composer could be beneficial. Overall, excellent work :)

Exposure to new challenges provokes a parallel process of self-assessment, stimulating the development of new values. Tops. Guevara’s realisation of widespread suffering, entrenched poverty and its destructive impact is elucidated in his exploration of the “graveyards of the mines”, metaphorically and physically symbolising the hardships faced by the proletariat, enabling the expansion of his world views. Nice amplification, links the idea nicely to the text in a very thematic/composer driven way, rather than plot. Nice. Similarly, when Guevara is confronted with the symptomatic deformation of disease in Columbia’s native population, “like a scene from a modern drama”, the observational simile further develops the brutality of South American living conditions. Great work integrating the quote into your idea, hard to do! The epiphanic tone in “it is at times like this, when a doctor is conscious of his complete powerlessness, that he longs for change”, spotlights the development of Guevara’s moral principle and alighted sense of duty to make meaningful change. The construction of Guevara’s new value system based on fresh knowledge and understanding spurred the rectification of his past beliefs, conveyed when he ironically states “they were in love with Uncle Sam”, demonstrating Guevara’s loss of ignorance to the exploitive and damaging influence of the US on Latin America. Be sure to be making links back to what the audience learns about Discovery more broadly - You are analysing the intents of the composer brilliantly, be sure to link to the greater understanding the audience gains on Discovery, in a broader sense (beyond the context of the text). The animal imagery in “the bestial howl of the triumphant proletariat” further symbolises Guevara’s conclusive embracement of socialist ideology and contingent solidification of his developed beliefs and values. Harrowing experiences stimulate the construction of personal ideals and principles by challenging and ultimately reshaping perceptions of the world. This conclusion seems a little disjointed from the rest of the paragraph, try adjusting a tad: "Thus, it is clear how Guevrara conveys... (insert the idea you mention here).

Contrary to Guevara’s epiphanic transformation in his viewpoints, Gregor’s emotional discoveries lead to the development of pessimistic perceptions of himself. Be careful, you have swapped to talking about a character rather than a composer. You are shifting slightly into retell - Try to focus on the composer primarily. The symbolism of “Gregor pull(ing) the sheet down lower” represents the protagonist’s decreasing level of self-respect revealed to be a consequence of his metamorphosis, whereby Gregor’s resentment of his family, a synecdoche for society as whole, catalyses his isolation from mankind. Good analysis again, but again, what does the audience realise about Discovery more broadly? There needs to be impact beyond the specifics of the texts context and characters. The stark contrast in tone in the family’s beliefs, at first concerned and then hateful “they were ready to help him”/“Gregor has to go,” instigates Gregor’s “conviction… that he would have to disappear”, the high modality language spotlighting Gregor’s realisation of the emptiness of humanity due to their opposition to individuals unfit to play a role in society because of their circumstance. That sentence a tad too long I think, be careful you don't try and do too much at once! Unlike Guevara, who embraced environmental challenges, Gregor denigrates his self-worth due to his inability to communicate with humanity, exposing the detrimental impact of his realisation of mankind’s unforgiving nature. Sort of retell, you are discussing a characters feelings and actions - The character is a construct of Kafka's, don't treat that character as a conscious entity. The reflective mood in “He remained in this state of empty and peaceful reflection...” at the novella’s denouncement illustrates Gregor’s obtainment of a new understanding to what satisfies him through the destruction of self for the desires of society, directing the protagonist in changing his view of life to achieve self-peace. Gregor and Guevara’s contrasting transformations in perceptions elucidate the way confronting realisations may instigate a process of differing self-assessments, catalysing the development of new values. Good analysis and comparisons between texts, but a tad too character focused. You should NEVER go a paragraph without mentioning the composer's name!

Consequently, retrospection upon the accumulation of past didactic experiences invigorates personal epiphanies and thus encourages the process of transformation. Another excellent conceptual start. Be sure you have room to adjust these to a question! The radicalisation of Guevara’s personal philosophy catalysed by the conglomeration of realisations is highlighted by the reflective tone of his thoughts concerning the dying woman in La Gioconda: “it is there, that one comprehends the profound tragedy circumscribing the life of the proletariat”. Be careful using plot elements as evidence, I know it isn't really here, but you could have used the technique and quote here without the plot detail if you catch me. Such reoccurring bildungsroman qualities of the memoir elucidate the maturation of Guevara’s thinking, the metaphor “I was a child of my environment” acknowledging his moral growth catalysed by his experiences. What does this show the audience more broadly? Thus, Guevara’s exposure to penury and exploitation of the marginalised social castes transforms him from a “dreamer” to a “revolutionary” political leader. Careful, this is retell! You've not linked to anything conceptual, you've just said what happens to the character. The juxtaposition of the gustatory imagery “savour” with the olfactory “acrid” in “savours the acrid smell of gunpowder and blood” creates a discomforting synaesthesia to accentuate his new devotion to the “people”, a metonym for the marginalised class in need of social justice. Guevara’s greatest epiphany is revealed in the vignette “tarata, the new world”, where after being confronted by the poverty of the Peruvians, he is emancipated from ignorance and political apathy, faced instead with metaphysical exhaustion symbolised by him being “frozen solid”, to be finally “welcomed with such friendliness” by strangers that changed him irreversibly. Bit of retell at the end here too. External discoveries stimulate the attainment of internal conclusions through a transformative process of reckoning with challenges, experiences, and values. Again, a little too text focused in this paragraph, and retell is starting to become more prominent in this paragraph as well - Be careful!

Furthermore, dependent on an individual’s context, the paradoxical nature of realisations enables both the progression and destruction of an individual. Be careful to link to your related text, don't just jump into the analysis assuming we'll follow. The rhetorical question “Did he really want the warm room… transformed into a lair?” signifies the inner conflict between Gregor’s human and insect instincts, elucidating how Gregor’s agonising experience of seclusion transforms his understanding of his own identity, no longer being able to classify himself as a constituent of humanity. See how you are analysing the character, a construct of the composer, rather than expanding into a broader consequence/understanding for the audience? The double entendre of “clean” in “everything was much too deep for him to have scrubbed himself clean”, depicts Gregor’s deterioration of his self-value and priorities of life as a result of his alienation from society, the dismal mood created further emphasising the demoralising impact of his personal discovery regarding the triviality of his existence. You don't need to identify the specific word related to a technique in a larger quote, you can just say "the double entendre in...". In contrast to Guevara’s conclusive transformation into a revolutionary, “Gregor shut himself off altogether”, symbolising how the seclusion Gregor experiences leads to his eventual downfall, revealing the duality of discovery as both a catalyst in the instigation of further realisations or a liquidator of individuals’ ambition to discover. THIS is what I need you to be doing with your analysis, linking to Discovery more broadly, this sentence particularly is just missing a proper technique.  Intensified by its relevance to one’s own context, discovery is inordinately powerful by leading to both new understandings and destroying untainted comprehensions of the self and the world.

Ultimately, the loss of ignorance by the attainment of new values and confronting knowledge influences one’s interpretation of the world, new judgements being developed through the unearthing of unfamiliar ideas and perspectives. However, whether a resultant transformation is advantageous or injurious, an individual will nevertheless be affected profoundly and irreversibly by their journey of discovery of the world. Nice bare bones conclusion, manipulate to the question to be most effective of course :)

I think this is definitely a strong essay kb! Sophisticated ideas, effective structure, and it seems like you've got wiggle room for different questions - Great! My biggest feedback would be to watch for being too text focused - Always link to broader Discovery related concepts, not just focus on the text specifically! ;D my comments throughout go into more detail on that and highlight a few other little nitpicks!

Is this a 15/15 if it answers the question well? Maybe, but I personally don't think so, I'd say you are in the 13/15 area right now, perhaps 14? It depends hugely on the question - But I'd want you to start adjusting your analytical style to be more abstract, and less text/plot/character focused, to start getting to 15/15 (in my opinion, of course) ;D

Thank you so much for the feedback! Sorry for replying so late, i was just super busy aha

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10150
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #439 on: September 03, 2017, 04:48:24 pm »
Thank you so much for the feedback! Sorry for replying so late, i was just super busy aha

aha no stress!! Good to have you back online ;D

kb123

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 74
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #440 on: September 03, 2017, 04:50:25 pm »
hi again, I was just wondering how many more posts i have to do to be eligible to send another piece for marking?

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10150
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #441 on: September 03, 2017, 04:51:56 pm »
hi again, I was just wondering how many more posts i have to do to be eligible to send another piece for marking?


85 :)

kb123

  • Forum Regular
  • **
  • Posts: 74
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #442 on: September 03, 2017, 04:57:32 pm »
also for the linking sentences in Discovery essays, should we include the author and text somehow or can we just make a broad statement about discovery that was represented by the text?

Here is an example of what I mean:

External discoveries stimulate the attainment of internal conclusions through a transformative process of reckoning with challenges and values.
VS.
Thus, Guevara’s textual representation of his discovery process articulates how external discoveries stimulate the attainment of internal conclusions through a transformative process of reckoning with challenges and values.



sorry i have a lot of questions at the moment.... since i am trying to fix up my essays before the hsc...

I need a technique for this quote:
"Gregor shut himself off"

I anyone has any ideas let me know! :)

Mod Edit: Post merge, you can add to your previous post if no one has answered it yet by using the 'Modify' button, to avoid double posting :)
« Last Edit: September 03, 2017, 05:54:55 pm by jamonwindeyer »

kaut2061

  • Fresh Poster
  • *
  • Posts: 4
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #443 on: September 03, 2017, 11:12:29 pm »
Im new to this website, and I am in desperate need as my trial marks were disgusting and my teacher isn't the greatest at marking and sending feed back. Can someone please help me! I've put my essay in the attachment below

elysepopplewell

  • HSC Lecturer
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Legend
  • *******
  • Posts: 3236
  • "Hey little fighter, soon it will be brighter."
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #444 on: September 04, 2017, 05:21:22 pm »
also for the linking sentences in Discovery essays, should we include the author and text somehow or can we just make a broad statement about discovery that was represented by the text?

Here is an example of what I mean:

External discoveries stimulate the attainment of internal conclusions through a transformative process of reckoning with challenges and values.
VS.
Thus, Guevara’s textual representation of his discovery process articulates how external discoveries stimulate the attainment of internal conclusions through a transformative process of reckoning with challenges and values.



sorry i have a lot of questions at the moment.... since i am trying to fix up my essays before the hsc...

I need a technique for this quote:
"Gregor shut himself off"

I anyone has any ideas let me know! :)

Mod Edit: Post merge, you can add to your previous post if no one has answered it yet by using the 'Modify' button, to avoid double posting :)

Your first question there -

The example you've given me kind of says to me that your first sentence would be the "linking" sentence you refer to, but the wording of the second sentence is really great, and you could use this as a sentence to end the paragraph before moving on to the next idea, I think!

I might need to see this in context to be 100% sure, though!

For the technique...it's a short sentence. Also, this is a reflexive statement. "Shut himself off."Another example of a reflexive statement is: "I got myself dressed." It's where the pronoun does something to itself - so I'd say this adds emphasis to the action by internalising it. He shut himself off - no one shut him off except him.
Not sure how to navigate around ATAR Notes? Check out this video!

Opengangs

  • New South Welsh
  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 718
  • \(\mathbb{O}_\mathbb{G}\)
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #445 on: September 04, 2017, 05:36:34 pm »
I would like feedback on my AoS essay.

To what extent do the texts you have studied reveal the way that discoveries can lead us to reassess values and see the world in new ways?

The powerful nature of discovery establishes a profound change and reassessment of values within the individual. Moreover, the values they possess are not static, but rather transformed through new perspectives and ideas. These ideas are exemplified through Ernesto "Che" Guevara’s memoir, The Motorcycle Diaries (1994), and Jorge Luis Borges’ elegy, O Destiny Of Borges, through the serendipitous nature of discovery and rediscovery. Ultimately, it is through the growth of the individual that the nature of discovery allows individuals to reassess their worth and see the world with new eyes.

The perception and nature of discovery is ultimately fertilised by an individual’s ideas, changed and transformed over time. It is through Che Guevara’s perspective that highlight the impacts of unexpected discoveries on the individual, and it is through this that individuals, like Guevara, begin to see the world with new eyes. Explored in The Motorcycle Diaries, the juxtaposition of tone between his opening vignette entry "so we understand each other" and his successive entries frames the text as a "discovery that becomes one of self-discovery". The metaphor and metonymy of “his feet touching [touched] Argentine soil again" reflects on Guevara’s transformation both, spiritually and mentally, inviting the audience to reflect on their own ideas of their world. His invitation is further enhanced by the use of inclusive pronouns as Guevara “leave(s) you now, with myself, the man I used to be…”, inducing the audience to experience his discoveries. Yet, his transformation is ultimately impelled by the physical discoveries of his journey around “our America with a big A”. The physical “discovery of the ocean” is personified as a “confidant; a friend absorbing all it is told and never revealing those secrets”, highlighting the impacts of a physical discovery to a spiritual realm. To Guevara, the ocean is portrayed as his spiritual transformation, leading individuals to re-establish their view of the world. As a result, the values Guevara encompass are changed and transformed through experiences. Only through experiences and journeys do individuals begin to reassess their values and view of the world.

Similarly, it is through new places and environments that individuals begin to stimulate new ideas and values, reassessing these ideas, and finally seeing the world in new ways. Through a stimulation of new worlds “of Edinburgh, of Zurich, of the two Cordobas”, Borges conveys discovery as one that is ever changing in both, its social and historical context. Borges accentuates the nature of discovery through the contrast, polysyndeton, and listing between contexts of “Colombia and of Texas” to “Andalucia, to Portugal”, demonstrating new perspectives of discoveries through the changes in context. Borges employment of metaphor “to have grown old in so many mirrors” reinstates that the nature of discovery is merely of an individual’s perspective. The symbolic nature of the “mirror” illustrates changing perspectives, and the exaggeration of ageing through the “growing [grown] old in so many mirrors” exemplify experiences of discoveries as one that is ever changing to the integrity of the individual. The repetition of the title, “Oh destiny of Borges”, highlights and frames the text as a discovery that in itself becomes a self-discovery; the play of time as the phrase is repeated at the end of the text symbolises an inner discovery of an individual, emphasising powers of self-worth and thus, recounts the discovery aspect as an ever changing process. It is through this notion that Borges highlights the need for new experiences and places to impel these notions of discovery on the individual, and it is through these new eyes that Borges accentuates the true worth of an individual’s values.

Ultimately, however, it is up to the individual to impel discoveries on themselves. The notion of reassessment of values stems from the necessities for individuals to be curious. Guevara’s journey of discoveries stem from his curiosity to explore South America. His values are transformed and changed through the serendipitous nature of discovery, impelled by his curiosity. The harsh description of the landscape through his sick state of mind as “his[my] head was like a drum hammering out strange rhythms” is contrasted with the vibrant landscape in his entry “dear mama”, describing the scenery as the “current [had] carried us toward the bank and some half-submerged branches nearly caused the raft to capsize”, highlighting his transforming worldview of South America. However, it is not just his mentality that is changed throughout the arduous journey; his state of emotion is transformed throughout the memoir. The “monotonous business of chasing visas” is exaggerated to accentuate his need to impel the nature of discovery and rediscovery on himself, inviting the audience to highlight his transformative desire through discoveries. Guevara’s description of the discovery of the ocean to both, himself and Granado, highlights the differing perspectives of discovery that stems from the curious minds of both travellers. The reaction of Granado’s discovery of the ocean as “a new, strangely perturbing sight” is vastly different to that of Guevara’s, who sees the ocean as a “confidant”, highlighting different perspectives of the same discovery. This, in turn, demonstrates the different perspectives that discovery can impel to individuals; through one object of discovery, many forms of discoveries can be revealed, demonstrating values that can be progressively reassessed over a longer period of time.

However, individuals can also impel discoveries on themselves through the re-experiences of the same journey, resulting in different perspectives of the same discovery. Borges demonstrates a desire to rediscover journeys through the listing and “questioning [questioned] of lithographs, encyclopedias, atlases”. Like Guevara, Borges highlights the desire to question their discoveries, resulting in a changed perception. The categorical listing of the scholarly books of encyclopedias and atlases demonstrates an intellectual discovery, while the categorical listing of “Andalucia, of the two Cordobas” convey a geographical discovery. Borges uses this notion of listing throughout the poem to emphasise the nature of discovery as one that is not obsolete to the individual, but rather it is a transformative process to the individual. The re-experiences of these discoveries are portrayed through the framing of the text, suggesting that the text is primarily an internal discovery. The description of the landscape as “the sluggish dawn, the plains” reinforce values as a purely transformative process, catalysed by the discoveries and rediscoveries within the individual. It is, then, through the progression of transformative means that individuals begin to appreciate the nature of discoveries, revealed through the shift of view within the individual, and through this shift in perception, individuals begin to view the world in new ways. Only then will pre-existing values be reassessed over a gradual period of time.

Within individuals, the nature of individuals is an ever changing process; it starts with a pre-existing idea and perception that is then moulded and transformed through experiences and new worlds. Moreover, the fertility and growth of the individual stems from their ability to reassess and challenge their pre-existing notions, in which the worldview of the individuals is evolved. Explored throughout Guevara’s The Motorcycle Diaries (1994) and Jorge Luis Borges’ elegy Oh Destiny of Borges, this idea becomes an integral element to the growth of the individuals, challenging notions within their respective worlds. It is through this fertility that individuals then begin to stimulate new ideas and ways to see the world with different lens, with the intention of reassessing old values.

I fear that my analysis isn't detailed enough and sustained.
Thanks!
« Last Edit: September 05, 2017, 08:51:15 pm by Opengangs »

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10150
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #446 on: September 04, 2017, 05:52:12 pm »
Im new to this website, and I am in desperate need as my trial marks were disgusting and my teacher isn't the greatest at marking and sending feed back. Can someone please help me! I've put my essay in the attachment below

Hey, welcome to the site! Thanks for posting your response, you need 25 posts on the site to qualify for feedback from one of the markers. One of your peers might be able to take a look in the meantime! ;D

The essay marking rules are here, for reference! ;D

DalvinT

  • Trendsetter
  • **
  • Posts: 188
  • We can always improve, right?
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #447 on: September 04, 2017, 06:04:44 pm »
Hey guys!
I would like to have my essay marked the last time haha. Need to get started on using a "polished" essay as my framework for all my practice essays :P
2017 HSC:
English Standard 91
Biology 90
Earth and Environmental Science 89
Music 1 97
Visual Arts 92
General Mathematics 2  85

ATAR : 95.15

2018-2020: Bachelor of Oral Health @ USYD

jamonwindeyer

  • Honorary Moderator
  • Great Wonder of ATAR Notes
  • *******
  • Posts: 10150
  • The lurker from the north.
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #448 on: September 08, 2017, 12:05:38 am »
I would like feedback on my AoS essay.
I fear that my analysis isn't detailed enough and sustained.
Thanks!

Hey hey, sure thing my friend!! Essay is attached with comments throughout ;D

Spoiler
To what extent do the texts you have studied reveal the way that discoveries can lead us to reassess values and see the world in new ways?

The powerful nature of discovery establishes a profound change and reassessment of values within the individual. Moreover, the values they possess are not static, but rather transformed through new perspectives and ideas. I feel like these two sentences are sort of saying the same thing? Discovery causes values to change. Values are changed through new perspectives. Feels a little awkward to me. These ideas are exemplified through Ernesto "Che" Guevara’s memoir, The Motorcycle Diaries (1994), and Jorge Luis Borges’ elegy, O Destiny Of Borges, through the serendipitous nature of discovery and rediscovery. Ultimately, it is through the growth of the individual that the nature of discovery allows individuals to reassess their worth and see the world with new eyes. Nice introduction on the whole. Leads with the concept and lets the text be the guide, not the other way around. Good work.

The perception and nature of discovery is ultimately fertilised by an individual’s ideas, changed and transformed over time. Good. It is through Che Guevara’s perspective that highlight the impacts of unexpected discoveries on the individual, and it is through this that individuals, like Guevara, begin to see the world with new eyes. Slightly awkward phrasing at the start there, and be careful you aren't being too text focused in how you present your concept. Right on the borderline right now. Explored in The Motorcycle Diaries, the juxtaposition of tone between his opening vignette entry "so we understand each other" and his successive entries frames the text as a "discovery that becomes one of self-discovery". The metaphor and metonymy of “his feet touching [touched] Argentine soil again" reflects on Guevara’s transformation both, spiritually and mentally, inviting the audience to reflect on their own ideas of their world. Good work connecting to the audience and the ideas of the question there, excellent work. His invitation is further enhanced by the use of inclusive pronouns as Guevara “leave(s) you now, with myself, the man I used to be…”, inducing the audience to experience his discoveries. Yet, his transformation is ultimately impelled by the physical discoveries of his journey around “our America with a big A”. The physical “discovery of the ocean” is personified as a “confidant; a friend absorbing all it is told and never revealing those secrets”, highlighting the impacts of a physical discovery to a spiritual realm. To Guevara, the ocean is portrayed as his spiritual transformation, leading individuals to re-establish their view of the world. Excellent. As a result, the values Guevara encompass are changed and transformed through experiences. Only through experiences and journeys do individuals begin to reassess their values and view of the world. A very solid analytical paragraph, you've delved into the intent and impact of the techniques extremely well. Make sure you aren't focusing too heavily on the text and persona, and drawing wider implications (which you did do on several occasions). Also be sure that your concepts stay completely on track with your topic sentence and don't wander!

Similarly, it is through new places and environments that individuals begin to stimulate new ideas and values, reassessing these ideas, and finally seeing the world in new ways. Good - Simple concept. Through a stimulation of new worlds “of Edinburgh, of Zurich, of the two Cordobas”, Borges conveys discovery as one that is ever changing in both, its social and historical context. Borges accentuates the nature of discovery through the contrast, polysyndeton, and listing between contexts of “Colombia and of Texas” to “Andalucia, to Portugal”, demonstrating new perspectives of discoveries through the changes in context. What is the nature? What are the new perspectives? Watch for sweeping statements like these. Borges employment of metaphor “to have grown old in so many mirrors” reinstates that the nature of discovery is merely of an individual’s perspective. The symbolic nature of the “mirror” illustrates changing perspectives, and the exaggeration of ageing through the “growing [grown] old in so many mirrors” exemplify experiences of discoveries as one that is ever changing to the integrity of the individual. This second sentence does an excellent job explaining what you mean by the one before it - If you could blend those last two sentences together, it would flow far more effectively. The repetition of the title, “Oh destiny of Borges”, highlights and frames the text as a discovery that in itself becomes a self-discovery; the play of time as the phrase is repeated at the end of the text symbolises an inner discovery of an individual, emphasising powers of self-worth and thus, recounts the discovery aspect as an ever changing process. Watch for sentences like this that are getting slightly too long - Don't be afraid to split up sentences where it needs it, just the same as joining them where it needs it. It is through this notion that Borges highlights the need for new experiences and places to impel these notions of discovery on the individual, and it is through these new eyes that Borges accentuates the true worth of an individual’s values.

Ultimately, however, it is up to the individual to impel discoveries on themselves. The notion of reassessment of values stems from the necessities for individuals to be curious. What are some of these necessities? Seems a little bit vague/confusing the way you've stated this right now. Guevara’s journey of discoveries stem from his curiosity to explore South America. His values are transformed and changed through the serendipitous nature of discovery, impelled by his curiosity. The harsh description of the landscape through his sick state of mind as “his[my] head was like a drum hammering out strange rhythms” is contrasted with the vibrant landscape in his entry “dear mama”, describing the scenery as the “current [had] carried us toward the bank and some half-submerged branches nearly caused the raft to capsize”, highlighting his transforming worldview of South America. Good work! Watch the length of your quotes, I reckon you could make them shorter and still communicate the same idea just as effectively. However, it is not just his mentality that is changed throughout the arduous journey; his state of emotion is transformed throughout the memoir. Watch for describing changes in the persona - This isn't contributing to your argument because you need to focus on concepts communicated to the audience, not changes in the characters/personalities that deliver those concepts. The “monotonous business of chasing visas” is exaggerated to accentuate his need to impel the nature of discovery and rediscovery on himself, inviting the audience to highlight his transformative desire through discoveries. Guevara’s description of the discovery of the ocean to both, himself and Granado, highlights the differing perspectives of discovery that stems from the curious minds of both travellers. The reaction of Granado’s discovery of the ocean as “a new, strangely perturbing sight” is vastly different to that of Guevara’s, who sees the ocean as a “confidant”, highlighting different perspectives of the same discovery. Careful, we are slipping a little into retell here. This, in turn, demonstrates the different perspectives that discovery can impel to individuals; through one object of discovery, many forms of discoveries can be revealed, demonstrating values that can be progressively reassessed over a longer period of time. This is a weaker paragraph analytically; there is a bit of retell at the end and the concepts aren't quite as clear to me as they should be. Work on simplicity, and ensure your concept is carried through - The idea of curiosity isn't really brought up after those first few sentences!

However, individuals can also impel discoveries on themselves through the re-experiences of the same journey, resulting in different perspectives of the same discovery. Slightly awkward wording there. Borges demonstrates a desire to rediscover journeys through the listing and “questioning [questioned] of lithographs, encyclopedias, atlases”. How does this listing accentuate the desire to rediscover journeys? Try and draw specific links between the technique and the impact. Like Guevara, Borges highlights the desire to question their discoveries, resulting in a changed perception. The categorical listing of the scholarly books of encyclopedias and atlases demonstrates an intellectual discovery, while the categorical listing of “Andalucia, of the two Cordobas” convey a geographical discovery. Borges uses this notion of listing throughout the poem to emphasise the nature of discovery as one that is not obsolete to the individual, but rather it is a transformative process to the individual. Again, not quite seeing how listing accentuates a transformative process. The re-experiences of these discoveries are portrayed through the framing of the text, suggesting that the text is primarily an internal discovery. The description of the landscape as “the sluggish dawn, the plains” reinforce values as a purely transformative process, catalysed by the discoveries and rediscoveries within the individual. Not quite following this concept, 'values' as a transformative process? Aren't values affected by the transformative process? It is, then, through the progression of transformative means that individuals begin to appreciate the nature of discoveries, revealed through the shift of view within the individual, and through this shift in perception, individuals begin to view the world in new ways. Only then will pre-existing values be reassessed over a gradual period of time.

Within individuals, the nature of individuals is an ever changing process; it starts with a pre-existing idea and perception that is then moulded and transformed through experiences and new worlds. The 'nature of individuals is an ever changing process,' doesn't quite make sense. The nature of individuals might be ever changing, but it isn't a process. Moreover, the fertility and growth of the individual stems from their ability to reassess and challenge their pre-existing notions, in which the worldview of the individuals is evolved. Explored throughout Guevara’s The Motorcycle Diaries (1994) and Jorge Luis Borges’ elegy Oh Destiny of Borges, this idea becomes an integral element to the growth of the individuals, challenging notions within their respective worlds. It is through this fertility that individuals then begin to stimulate new ideas and ways to see the world with different lens, with the intention of reassessing old values.

This is a very effective essay in terms of the analysis - Lots of quotes, lots of technique, frequent references to the audience. All excellent. And you've answered the question effectively as well. I think conceptual clarity needs a bit of work, particularly in the later paragraphs, some wording issues and gaps in explanations make it quite difficult to tie parts of your argument together, and can lead to you getting off track a bit (I noticed this particularly in the curiosity paragraph). Watch out for this, keep things simple, avoid sweeping/vague statements, and keep running paragraphs by your peers (and us) to check if they can follow what you are saying.

Additionally, try to draw stronger links between the technique used and the impact on the audience! Some of the links you drew out were a tad dubious in terms of what the technique and quote were accomplishing conceptually, try to make it natural! That is, literary techniques normally accentuate ideas. Metaphors and figurative language are used to draw greater meaning out of everyday scenarios. Imagery makes things relatable. Etc, etc ;D

An effective essay though Opengangs! Nicely done :)

Opengangs

  • New South Welsh
  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 718
  • \(\mathbb{O}_\mathbb{G}\)
Re: Free AOS essay Marking!
« Reply #449 on: September 08, 2017, 12:30:02 am »
Hey hey, sure thing my friend!! Essay is attached with comments throughout ;D

Spoiler
To what extent do the texts you have studied reveal the way that discoveries can lead us to reassess values and see the world in new ways?

The powerful nature of discovery establishes a profound change and reassessment of values within the individual. Moreover, the values they possess are not static, but rather transformed through new perspectives and ideas. I feel like these two sentences are sort of saying the same thing? Discovery causes values to change. Values are changed through new perspectives. Feels a little awkward to me. These ideas are exemplified through Ernesto "Che" Guevara’s memoir, The Motorcycle Diaries (1994), and Jorge Luis Borges’ elegy, O Destiny Of Borges, through the serendipitous nature of discovery and rediscovery. Ultimately, it is through the growth of the individual that the nature of discovery allows individuals to reassess their worth and see the world with new eyes. Nice introduction on the whole. Leads with the concept and lets the text be the guide, not the other way around. Good work.

The perception and nature of discovery is ultimately fertilised by an individual’s ideas, changed and transformed over time. Good. It is through Che Guevara’s perspective that highlight the impacts of unexpected discoveries on the individual, and it is through this that individuals, like Guevara, begin to see the world with new eyes. Slightly awkward phrasing at the start there, and be careful you aren't being too text focused in how you present your concept. Right on the borderline right now. Explored in The Motorcycle Diaries, the juxtaposition of tone between his opening vignette entry "so we understand each other" and his successive entries frames the text as a "discovery that becomes one of self-discovery". The metaphor and metonymy of “his feet touching [touched] Argentine soil again" reflects on Guevara’s transformation both, spiritually and mentally, inviting the audience to reflect on their own ideas of their world. Good work connecting to the audience and the ideas of the question there, excellent work. His invitation is further enhanced by the use of inclusive pronouns as Guevara “leave(s) you now, with myself, the man I used to be…”, inducing the audience to experience his discoveries. Yet, his transformation is ultimately impelled by the physical discoveries of his journey around “our America with a big A”. The physical “discovery of the ocean” is personified as a “confidant; a friend absorbing all it is told and never revealing those secrets”, highlighting the impacts of a physical discovery to a spiritual realm. To Guevara, the ocean is portrayed as his spiritual transformation, leading individuals to re-establish their view of the world. Excellent. As a result, the values Guevara encompass are changed and transformed through experiences. Only through experiences and journeys do individuals begin to reassess their values and view of the world. A very solid analytical paragraph, you've delved into the intent and impact of the techniques extremely well. Make sure you aren't focusing too heavily on the text and persona, and drawing wider implications (which you did do on several occasions). Also be sure that your concepts stay completely on track with your topic sentence and don't wander!

Similarly, it is through new places and environments that individuals begin to stimulate new ideas and values, reassessing these ideas, and finally seeing the world in new ways. Good - Simple concept. Through a stimulation of new worlds “of Edinburgh, of Zurich, of the two Cordobas”, Borges conveys discovery as one that is ever changing in both, its social and historical context. Borges accentuates the nature of discovery through the contrast, polysyndeton, and listing between contexts of “Colombia and of Texas” to “Andalucia, to Portugal”, demonstrating new perspectives of discoveries through the changes in context. What is the nature? What are the new perspectives? Watch for sweeping statements like these. Borges employment of metaphor “to have grown old in so many mirrors” reinstates that the nature of discovery is merely of an individual’s perspective. The symbolic nature of the “mirror” illustrates changing perspectives, and the exaggeration of ageing through the “growing [grown] old in so many mirrors” exemplify experiences of discoveries as one that is ever changing to the integrity of the individual. This second sentence does an excellent job explaining what you mean by the one before it - If you could blend those last two sentences together, it would flow far more effectively. The repetition of the title, “Oh destiny of Borges”, highlights and frames the text as a discovery that in itself becomes a self-discovery; the play of time as the phrase is repeated at the end of the text symbolises an inner discovery of an individual, emphasising powers of self-worth and thus, recounts the discovery aspect as an ever changing process. Watch for sentences like this that are getting slightly too long - Don't be afraid to split up sentences where it needs it, just the same as joining them where it needs it. It is through this notion that Borges highlights the need for new experiences and places to impel these notions of discovery on the individual, and it is through these new eyes that Borges accentuates the true worth of an individual’s values.

Ultimately, however, it is up to the individual to impel discoveries on themselves. The notion of reassessment of values stems from the necessities for individuals to be curious. What are some of these necessities? Seems a little bit vague/confusing the way you've stated this right now. Guevara’s journey of discoveries stem from his curiosity to explore South America. His values are transformed and changed through the serendipitous nature of discovery, impelled by his curiosity. The harsh description of the landscape through his sick state of mind as “his[my] head was like a drum hammering out strange rhythms” is contrasted with the vibrant landscape in his entry “dear mama”, describing the scenery as the “current [had] carried us toward the bank and some half-submerged branches nearly caused the raft to capsize”, highlighting his transforming worldview of South America. Good work! Watch the length of your quotes, I reckon you could make them shorter and still communicate the same idea just as effectively. However, it is not just his mentality that is changed throughout the arduous journey; his state of emotion is transformed throughout the memoir. Watch for describing changes in the persona - This isn't contributing to your argument because you need to focus on concepts communicated to the audience, not changes in the characters/personalities that deliver those concepts. The “monotonous business of chasing visas” is exaggerated to accentuate his need to impel the nature of discovery and rediscovery on himself, inviting the audience to highlight his transformative desire through discoveries. Guevara’s description of the discovery of the ocean to both, himself and Granado, highlights the differing perspectives of discovery that stems from the curious minds of both travellers. The reaction of Granado’s discovery of the ocean as “a new, strangely perturbing sight” is vastly different to that of Guevara’s, who sees the ocean as a “confidant”, highlighting different perspectives of the same discovery. Careful, we are slipping a little into retell here. This, in turn, demonstrates the different perspectives that discovery can impel to individuals; through one object of discovery, many forms of discoveries can be revealed, demonstrating values that can be progressively reassessed over a longer period of time. This is a weaker paragraph analytically; there is a bit of retell at the end and the concepts aren't quite as clear to me as they should be. Work on simplicity, and ensure your concept is carried through - The idea of curiosity isn't really brought up after those first few sentences!

However, individuals can also impel discoveries on themselves through the re-experiences of the same journey, resulting in different perspectives of the same discovery. Slightly awkward wording there. Borges demonstrates a desire to rediscover journeys through the listing and “questioning [questioned] of lithographs, encyclopedias, atlases”. How does this listing accentuate the desire to rediscover journeys? Try and draw specific links between the technique and the impact. Like Guevara, Borges highlights the desire to question their discoveries, resulting in a changed perception. The categorical listing of the scholarly books of encyclopedias and atlases demonstrates an intellectual discovery, while the categorical listing of “Andalucia, of the two Cordobas” convey a geographical discovery. Borges uses this notion of listing throughout the poem to emphasise the nature of discovery as one that is not obsolete to the individual, but rather it is a transformative process to the individual. Again, not quite seeing how listing accentuates a transformative process. The re-experiences of these discoveries are portrayed through the framing of the text, suggesting that the text is primarily an internal discovery. The description of the landscape as “the sluggish dawn, the plains” reinforce values as a purely transformative process, catalysed by the discoveries and rediscoveries within the individual. Not quite following this concept, 'values' as a transformative process? Aren't values affected by the transformative process? It is, then, through the progression of transformative means that individuals begin to appreciate the nature of discoveries, revealed through the shift of view within the individual, and through this shift in perception, individuals begin to view the world in new ways. Only then will pre-existing values be reassessed over a gradual period of time.

Within individuals, the nature of individuals is an ever changing process; it starts with a pre-existing idea and perception that is then moulded and transformed through experiences and new worlds. The 'nature of individuals is an ever changing process,' doesn't quite make sense. The nature of individuals might be ever changing, but it isn't a process. Moreover, the fertility and growth of the individual stems from their ability to reassess and challenge their pre-existing notions, in which the worldview of the individuals is evolved. Explored throughout Guevara’s The Motorcycle Diaries (1994) and Jorge Luis Borges’ elegy Oh Destiny of Borges, this idea becomes an integral element to the growth of the individuals, challenging notions within their respective worlds. It is through this fertility that individuals then begin to stimulate new ideas and ways to see the world with different lens, with the intention of reassessing old values.

This is a very effective essay in terms of the analysis - Lots of quotes, lots of technique, frequent references to the audience. All excellent. And you've answered the question effectively as well. I think conceptual clarity needs a bit of work, particularly in the later paragraphs, some wording issues and gaps in explanations make it quite difficult to tie parts of your argument together, and can lead to you getting off track a bit (I noticed this particularly in the curiosity paragraph). Watch out for this, keep things simple, avoid sweeping/vague statements, and keep running paragraphs by your peers (and us) to check if they can follow what you are saying.

Additionally, try to draw stronger links between the technique used and the impact on the audience! Some of the links you drew out were a tad dubious in terms of what the technique and quote were accomplishing conceptually, try to make it natural! That is, literary techniques normally accentuate ideas. Metaphors and figurative language are used to draw greater meaning out of everyday scenarios. Imagery makes things relatable. Etc, etc ;D

An effective essay though Opengangs! Nicely done :)
Thankyou for the wonderful feedback!! I would like to know where I stand in terms of mark for this, so what would give this essay out of 15?

Thanks again!