Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

March 29, 2024, 09:04:19 pm

Author Topic: Burial Rites- Prompt help  (Read 2839 times)  Share 

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

ooft

  • Adventurer
  • *
  • Posts: 13
  • Respect: 0
Burial Rites- Prompt help
« on: April 06, 2017, 03:03:29 pm »
0
So, i'm meant to be writing a practice SAC on this prompt:
"Natan shouts: “Remember your place, Agnes!” ‘Agnes’s problem is that she has no place to belong.’ Do you agree?"

I'm having trouble actually thinking of arguments to make concerning the prompt. Has anyone actually done this prompt before? and if so, can you give me some ideas about what to write about. Thanks. 

Benji414

  • Adventurer
  • *
  • Posts: 10
  • Respect: 0
Re: Burial Rites- Prompt help
« Reply #1 on: May 03, 2017, 10:16:03 am »
0
Hey Man,
Ive attempted this topic for a Practise Sac,
Tell me what you think!!


Natan shouts: “Remember your place, Agnes!” ‘Agnes’s problem is that she has no place

to belong.’ Do you agree




Kent’s novel “Burial Rites” depicts the journey of Agnes Magnusdottir and her struggle to fit into a society

that is different. Amidst the populace, Agnes is caged by labels that prevent her from attaining a sense of

belonging. Furthermore, her endeavour to belong is sensed through the presence of Natan but soon

diminishes over the time of his death. Despite this, the author ends on an optimistic note. The presence of

the family at Kornsa, reignites a sense of belonging within Agnes and deems her as one who is accepted.




The labels and depictions shunned on Agnes inhibits societies choice to offer her a place. Through the death

of Natan Ketilsson Agnes’ sense of identity is fragmented by her status as a ‘murderess’. The notion that

Agnes is now seen as 'an inhumane witch, stirring up murder' reveals her inability to reconcile her identity

within society. Kent exemplifies society’s misperception of Agnes through the appearance of Rosa, deeming

her as an outsider. Agnes is misperceived by the crowd gathered around her as the “Fjandi! Devil”, as she

feels the ‘comfort’ of Rosa, ‘someone [she] recognised’. That presenting Rosa’s disappearance at the

remark of the crowd, the only person she could recognise, Kent implies that society has ultimately betrayed

Agnes at the cause of their own portrayals of her. Furthermore, her description as being “too clever” is not

favourably looked upon by society. Even Agnes believes that society withholds their pity and acceptance of

her. As through the presence of knowing her to be “too smart”, she deviates from the common role as a

female, representing something unordinary, witch-like, as they say; “...a thinking woman cannot be

trusted”. This proposition amongst other depictions inevitably leads to Agnes inability to belong in society.





Natan’s nurturing of Agnes offers her a near ample place of acceptance. Agnes feature of a hollow palm

epitomises an ‘empty space’ that she resides in, a state of unacceptance in society. Metaphorically, through

the conception of the hollow palm as suggested by Natan, she can only attain that space through their

inseparability, ‘by covering it’ with his own hands. Being ‘offered...friendship’ she conceals herself further

from ‘the world’ and society and clings onto him as ‘[they’re] the same kind’. In spite of this new hope,

Natan allays their future and ‘becomes more of a stranger’ to her. His love for her oscillates and eventually

dries up at the company of Sigga. Although initially he ‘made [her] feel [she] was enough’ and would ‘haul

[her] out of her ‘loveless life,’ ‘all that while, there was sigga.’ That the conception of her struggle to belong

is near but not yet complete reveals Agnes ultimate struggle to fit in, even with Natan.





Kent’s novel, however, closes on an optimistic note. Agnes is now the property of the family at Kornsa and

‘had seemed part of the family’. The burning of Agnes’ dress as executed by Margret symbolizes the

removal of Agnes’ past and her history of isolation and ossifying a new identity within the Kornsa family.

Treating her in a ‘familiar way... like a sister’, the family acknowledge that she is ‘not a monster’ and that ‘it

wasn’t her fault.’ By removing the label placed on Agnes, the family are able to accept her for who she is

rather than the ‘things [she’s] done’, thus acknowledging her humanity, an act that society could never

take. Additionally, Margret’s act of placing the few items of beauty owned by the family beside Agnes

reveals that she has attained acceptance. Here, Kent implicitly depicts Agnes as one who will walk to the

execution shrouded not in the grey clothes of a servant but in the warmth of clothing and accessories that

show that she was someone, that she belonged.



The pervasive idea to belong as attempted by Agnes in Kent’s Burial Rites is hindered by many obstacles.

Social norms and stigmas prevent Agnes from ever attaining a sense of belonging. Natan’s acceptance of

Agnes ignites a personal sense of belonging which too is quenched. However, the reader is left with an

overwhelming sense of optimism. Agnes acceptance, offered by the family at Kornsa, reassures her that she

will be ‘remember[ed]’, that she has found her ‘place’.