Login

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

April 24, 2024, 03:52:36 pm

Author Topic: Please check sonnet? (Year 10 English)  (Read 3940 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

geminii

  • Victorian
  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 787
  • Do or do not, there is no try.
  • Respect: +42
Please check sonnet? (Year 10 English)
« on: September 07, 2015, 09:24:20 pm »
0
Hi everyone  :D

Sorry, I am unable to delete this topic but I have already submitted my poem.
Thanks for the help :)
« Last Edit: September 09, 2015, 02:13:40 pm by AceVCE777 »
2016-17 (VCE): Biology, HHD, English, Methods, Specialist, Chemistry

2018-22: Bachelor of Biomedical Science @ Monash Uni

heids

  • Supreme Stalker
  • Honorary Moderator
  • ATAR Notes Superstar
  • *******
  • Posts: 2429
  • Respect: +1632
Re: Please check sonnet? (Year 10 English)
« Reply #1 on: September 07, 2015, 09:53:15 pm »
0
Thou art the Princess of noble Feysville
And one day he’ll become the Kingdom’s Sire.
Your love and his, I had bid but goodwill
But my love for you burns brighter than fire.

O Maude, thine beauty cuts sharp like a knife
Thou hath tresses more exquisite than gold.
He gave you his heart but I’ll give you life
To save none but you, I’d give up my soul.

O Maude, an angel on earth I have found
Thou hath more beauty than stars in the sky.
Thine angelic love leaves me e’er spellbound
Why then, would you give your love to a lie?

The Prince of noble Feysville he may be
But, O Maude, darling, give your love to me.


DISCLAIMER: I know nothing.

- length good
- rhyming good
- number of syllables good, but rhythm dodgyish
10 syllables isn't automatically correct; rhythm is about emphasis on syllables.  It doesn't always gel right given that we place emphasis on different syllables, given the word and flow of the sentence.  Can't 100% help you out though because I don't get the rhythm of 10-syllable poetry that well, it always sounds slightly off to me.
An example: 'princess'.  The emphasis in normal English is PRIN-cess, and FEYS-ville.  Try to say that a few different ways, in rhythm, and see if you can get that first line to work.  I can't, without twisting it a bit, and then it doesn't quite fit with the next line (you simply can't put emphasis on 'the', for example)... maybe I've just missed the way that 'clicks', however, so no guarantees! :)
- spelling/grammar good, except:
'thine beauty' should be 'thy beauty'
'thou hath' should be 'thou hast'
'thine angelic love' should be 'thy angelic love' ('thine' essentially equals 'yours', 'thy' equals 'your')
And I didn't get this line:
Your love and his, I had bid but goodwill

My perception of storyline: Sounds pretty much like she's married this prince bloke and the speaker of the sonnet is saying 'give up on him and come to me because you'll find I love you more than he does in reality, his love's a bit of a fake'.  Or something.

Not bad though, de-finitely not bad.  Catch me writing sonnets. (have you seen the one in Lauren's sig? lol)
VCE (2014): HHD, Bio, English, T&T, Methods

Uni (2021-24): Bachelor of Nursing @ Monash Clayton

Work: PCA in residential aged care

geminii

  • Victorian
  • Forum Leader
  • ****
  • Posts: 787
  • Do or do not, there is no try.
  • Respect: +42
Re: Please check sonnet? (Year 10 English)
« Reply #2 on: September 07, 2015, 10:02:19 pm »
0
DISCLAIMER: I know nothing.

- length good
- rhyming good
- number of syllables good, but rhythm dodgyish
10 syllables isn't automatically correct; rhythm is about emphasis on syllables.  It doesn't always gel right given that we place emphasis on different syllables, given the word and flow of the sentence.  Can't 100% help you out though because I don't get the rhythm of 10-syllable poetry that well, it always sounds slightly off to me.
An example: 'princess'.  The emphasis in normal English is PRIN-cess, and FEYS-ville.  Try to say that a few different ways, in rhythm, and see if you can get that first line to work.  I can't, without twisting it a bit, and then it doesn't quite fit with the next line (you simply can't put emphasis on 'the', for example)... maybe I've just missed the way that 'clicks', however, so no guarantees! :)
- spelling/grammar good, except:
'thine beauty' should be 'thy beauty'
'thou hath' should be 'thou hast'
'thine angelic love' should be 'thy angelic love' ('thine' essentially equals 'yours', 'thy' equals 'your')
And I didn't get this line:
Your love and his, I had bid but goodwill

My perception of storyline: Sounds pretty much like she's married this prince bloke and the speaker of the sonnet is saying 'give up on him and come to me because you'll find I love you more than he does in reality, his love's a bit of a fake'.  Or something.

Not bad though, de-finitely not bad.  Catch me writing sonnets. (have you seen the one in Lauren's sig? lol)

Thanks so much! Yeah you pretty much got the plot :D
Basically the line: Your love and his, I had bid but goodwill means that the guy had told her and the prince guy that it was ok they were getting married. Like, I had bid you goodwill for his and her love. If that makes sense? Do you think there's a better way to say that?

Yes I could tell the rhythm was a bit off. Do you think there's anything I could change to improve it? I thought maybe changing some words but I just can't seem to get it to 'click'... :-\

Thanks again :D
2016-17 (VCE): Biology, HHD, English, Methods, Specialist, Chemistry

2018-22: Bachelor of Biomedical Science @ Monash Uni